Home page -> Comparison -> ATFX vs City Index | Broker Comparison

ATFX vs City Index | Broker Comparison

Best trading broker comparisons. We compared ATFX broker with City Index to see what key differences we could find.

Our goal was to create a side by side comparison of the approved brokers on wecomparebrokers to give you an at-a-glance overview of their features, broker details and fees. Our broker reviews and comparisons done by us testing accounts with real money and from the traders view point. You can also use our broker finder to look for a broker specific to your requirements.

Below is a comparison between ATFX vs City Index.

In our testing, we used our trading accounts and ranked various points that we liked, did not like or were indifferent to. We tried to be objective and be fair minded when evaluating certain characteristics, based on what features the broker had to offer in compared with how competitive their fees are. Additionally, we have created our own unique rating system which use for judging all brokers in our side-by-side broker comparisons.

ATFX Review

City Index Review

Basic Information

Year Founded

First broker:

2014

Second broker:

1983

Headquarters Location

First broker:

St. Vincent&Grenadines, London

Second broker:

UK (US Parent) + Global Offices

Publicly Traded (Entity or Parent)

First broker:

YES

Second broker:

YES

Regulated?

First broker:

YES

Second broker:

YES

Primary Regulator

First broker:

FCA

Second broker:

FCA

Minimum Deposit

First broker:

$100

Second broker:

£100

Fixed Spreads?

First broker:

Second broker:

Trading Type

First broker:

No Dealing Desk, STP

Second broker:

Market Maker

Commissions on Trades

First broker:

YES

Second broker:

CFD Loss Rate

First broker:

71% loss rate on CFDs

Second broker:

72% loss rate on CFDs

Maximum Leverage

First broker:

1:200

Second broker:

1:30

Currency Pairs Offered

First broker:

Second broker:

General Average Rating - 3 scale

First broker:

2,05

Second broker:

2,28

Background

Value

Score

Value

Score

Year Founded

First broker:

2014

2,0

Second broker:

1983

3,0

Headquarters location + Offices

First broker:

St. Vincent&Grenadines, London

2,0

Second broker:

UK (US Parent) + Global Offices

3,0

Publicly traded?

First broker:

1,5

Second broker:

Owned by GAIN Capital (Yes)

3,0

Size Measure

First broker:

Private - No public data

1,5

Second broker:

800+ employees worlwide

2,5

Summary Score

First broker:

1,75

Second broker:

2,88

Regulatory Compliance

Value

Score

Value

Score

Regulated or unregulated?

First broker:

YES

3,0

Second broker:

YES

3,0

Primary regulator

First broker:

FCA

3,0

Second broker:

FCA

3,0

Multiple compliance

First broker:

CySEC, St. Vincent

2,0

Second broker:

ASIC, Singapore, Dubai,

3,0

Safety of Deposits

First broker:

Safe if UK or EU

2,0

Second broker:

UK protect, no additional ins

2,5

Summary Score

First broker:

2,50

Second broker:

2,88

Fees & Charges

Value

Score

Value

Score

Commissions, Fees & Charges

First broker:

2 accts, pricing varies

2,5

Second broker:

Average

2,0

General

First broker:

Fairly competitive, NDD

2,5

Second broker:

High transparency, options fees?

2,0

Spreads

First broker:

Fairly competitive, NDD

2,5

Second broker:

Fixed and variable confusing

2,0

Summary Score

First broker:

2,50

Second broker:

2,00

Investment Products

Value

Score

Value

Score

Stocks - Breadth

First broker:

Only over 100 products

1,0

Second broker:

4 000

2,5

Forex - Breadth

First broker:

Average

2,5

Second broker:

Average

2,5

Other: Comm, Crypto, Spread, CFD?

First broker:

Comm, Crypto, CFD, Options, SB

3,0

Second broker:

Comm, Cryp, CFD, Spread Betting

3,0

Summary Score

First broker:

2,17

Second broker:

2,67

Platform experience

Value

Score

Value

Score

MT4 or equivalant

First broker:

MT4

3,0

Second broker:

MT4

3,0

Proprietary options

First broker:

Also MT4 WebTrader Platform

2,5

Second broker:

Web and AT Pro platforms

2,5

Special Advanced?

First broker:

Auto-trade and Scalping OK

2,0

Second broker:

Reuters feed, advanced tools

2,0

Summary Score

First broker:

2,50

Second broker:

2,50

Special Features

Value

Score

Value

Score

Feature A

First broker:

STP broker

2,5

Second broker:

Still operates dealing desk

1,0

Feature B

First broker:

Popular assets, limited

1,5

Second broker:

No volume discounts

1,5

Feature C

First broker:

No social trading

1,0

Second broker:

No social trading

1,0

Summary Score

First broker:

1,67

Second broker:

1,17

Research Tools/Guidance

Value

Score

Value

Score

Financial Commentary

First broker:

Access to Tradng Cntral feed

2,5

Second broker:

Above average research portal

2,5

Technical Anlaysis

First broker:

Access to Tradng Cntral feed

2,5

Second broker:

In-house analyst updates

2,5

Other Guidance

First broker:

Focus on experienced traders

2,0

Second broker:

Trading ideas, stratagies

2,0

Summary Score

First broker:

2,33

Second broker:

2,33

Education Support

Value

Score

Value

Score

Basic Library

First broker:

Minimal, if at all

0,5

Second broker:

Basic to Broad coverage

2,0

Webinars/Support

First broker:

Daily webinars

1,5

Second broker:

Webinars, videos, articles

2,0

General

First broker:

71% loss rate on CFDs

1,5

Second broker:

72% loss rate on CFDs

1,5

Summary Score

First broker:

1,17

Second broker:

1,83

Customer Support

Value

Score

Value

Score

Live Chat, Web, Tele, Offices

First broker:

YES

3,0

Second broker:

YES

3,0

Responsiveness

First broker:

2 mins for chat, day for email

2,5

Second broker:

Better than Average

2,5

FAQs? Quality?

First broker:

Below average

1,5

Second broker:

More than adequate

2,5

Summary Score

First broker:

2,33

Second broker:

2,67

General Pros & Cons

Value

Score

Value

Score

Pro #1

First broker:

No Dealing Desk

2,5

Second broker:

Competitive pricing

2,0

Pro #2

First broker:

Free access to research prov

2,0

Second broker:

Large product offering

2,5

Pro #3

First broker:

Scalp, hedge, and EAs OK

2,0

Second broker:

Excellent training/support

2,5

Con #1

First broker:

No educational resources

1,0

Second broker:

Focus on begin and mid-level

2,0

Con #2

First broker:

Only 100 assets to trade

1,0

Second broker:

Advanced API integration weak

1,0

Con #3

First broker:

No social trading

1,0

Second broker:

No social trading

1,0

Summary Score

First broker:

1,58

Second broker:

1,83

General Average Rating - 3 scale

First broker:

2,05

Second broker:

2,28